Boldly going where no blog has gone before…well ok maybe not…
By dipthegeezer
So here are my thoughts on the new Star Trek Movie. Generally it was good and I have to say I enjoyed it at the time of watching. Though after the movie was over I seemd to take it to pieces in my head to such a degree that I actually ended up thinking it wasn’t that great as I first thought. Here’s why:
The plot has more holes then swiss cheese..see next point
Stay away from time travel stories…they never work
How can a bunch of young people who have only just graduated from the academy be, by the end of the film, top officers on the FLAGSHIP of the federation…THE FLAGSHIP! Kirk goes from graduate to Captain in an astonishingly short time
Spock getting angry reminded me too much of Sylar…Seriously there is one point in the movie where he grabs Kirk by he neck and I swear he was going to do his “finger slice top of head to steal powers shtick”
Marooning Kirk on a frozen planet with hardly enough equipment to survive surely goes against all Geneva conventions concerning mutinous crew…well they are in space so maybe the federation dropped the Geneva convention..what was wrong with sending him to the brig like any sane captian would do?
Lucky though that considering the size of the planet he was able to land not too far from Old Spock
Little Monster being eaten by big monster…that scene annoyed me and I didn’t know quite why and then it hit me…they had the exact same sequence in The Phantom Menace!!!
Anyway as reboots so bad that it would get me angry and I did enjoy it far more then the travesty that was Wolverine….
This entry was posted on May 17, 2009 at 12:23 am and is filed under Film. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.
You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
May 17, 2009 at 4:51 pm |
When Spock “maroons” Kirk, he leaves him near to a Starfleet base. Remember he wasn’t supposed to be on the Enterprise in the first place, and why take him into a battle where he wouldn’t be used and might be killed? If he’d stayed in his pod, he’d have been safe until Starfleet came to pick him up. Kirk’s impetuous, so he gets out and starts exploring (despite the warning from the onboard computer), but leaving him on the planet wasn’t crazy or particularly cruel.
I feel differently on some of the other points, but I think I’ll just post my own review at some point.